Diverse Crowd Attends Forum on Islamophobia
A "rainbow" of people showed up last Saturday morning to hear several panelists discuss Islamophobia in Montgomery County.
A diverse crowd gathered at the Wisconsin Place Community Center last Saturday to show support for Muslims in American society.
The forum, at which several civil rights activists and legal scholars spoke—was organized in response to the Chevy Chase Women’s Republican Club’s invitation to conservative commentator Fred Grandy (who has said that there are risks associated with having Muslims working in U.S. government) to speak at a private club event last Saturday evening.
“[Let’s] fight bad speech with good speech,” said Saqib Ali—a member of the Maryland House of Delegates from 2007 to 2011 representing Gaithersburg and Germantown, and an organizer of the Saturday morning forum—to cheers from the audience.
“[Let’s] have … a debate with an open public forum … because we have nothing to hide. “ Ali added.
The speakers at the forum included Jamie Raskin (Maryland state senator and professor of constitutional law at American University), Corey Saylor (national legislative director for the Council on American-Islamic Relations), Shahid Buttar (a recording artist and civil rights lawyer), Sulayman Nyang (a professor of African Studies at Howard University) and civil liberties activist Thomas Nephew.
Grandy (or a designated representative) was also invited to speak at the forum, but his seat at the forum table remained empty.
Elizabeth Lakew—Montgomery Blair High School student, secretary of the High School Democrats of Maryland, and the one who initially brought the Chevy Chase Women’s Republican Club’s event to the attention of Maryland Juice—introduced the forum and its speakers.
“I didn’t believe it at first because I could not fathom any human being holding such hatred to a group of people that subscribed to a religion that preached peace and understanding,” Lakew said of her thoughts when she first learned of the Republican Club’s invitation to Grandy.
“My agitation soon manifested itself into action,” and Lakew’s action led to the Saturday morning forum.
“I am actually disappointed that Mr. Grandy didn’t accept the invitation to speak," Saylor said.
“I am happy to debate him, as long as we agree on a format and that we agree that we are both Americans who have our nation’s best interests at heart,” Saylor added.
"I have no power to suppress someone’s free speech … [but] I believe that biased speech should not be given a [legitimate] platform. … You cannot allow biased speech to creep from the fringe to the mainstream,” Saylor said.
"[Biased speech] … is unacceptable against Catholics … Jews … Blacks … and it must be unacceptable against Muslims,” he added.
“Discriminating against a religion as a whole will not solve our problems,” Lakew said.
“It will not stop terrorism, it will not stop the organized regimes that elicit violence, and it will not stop the deep-rooted hatred that we have formed about one another based on making some things up, taking things out of context and dramatically twisting the tradition to which many people belong,” she added.
Regarding a recent trend in state governments to attempt to pass legislation against the imposition of Shariah law, Raskin pointed out that the first amendment of the U.S. Constitution already provides for the freedom of religion, and that the U.S. has a “long body of case law” that protects American society from the imposition of any religious laws.
“We don’t need any of the statues that are being suggested” by conservative lawmakers, Raskin said.
“We have a well-developed case law to deal with ... these questions … [which] suggests to me that the campaign [for anti-Shariah bills] is one of political propaganda.”
But, Buttar disagreed with Raskin by asserting that “the freedoms that we have taken for granted no longer exist.”
Videos of the forum can be seen on the Montgomery County Civil Rights Coalition's YouTube channel.
Mahmoud El-Darwish
12:25 pm on Thursday, September 29, 2011
Islamophobia was the invention of the Bush era 'think tanks'. It's good to remind everyone the roots of current so-called 'Islamophobia' extend to well before 9-11.The reason it's important is that is underscores the aforementioned agenda as being 'political' versus reality driven. in brief: when the Soviet Communism collapsed, Arabs, Muslims and an Middle-Eastern country sitting on oil reserves became the new scapegoat for the Military Industrial Complex. By fomenting discontent by, isolation and suspicion of orthodox muslims after 9-11, the stage was set for a redirection of frustrations by a recently slighted and disenfranchised hard core bigoted sector of American society . This has functioned well as a distraction from the root cause of America's recent economic and geopolitical disasters.
Understanding this, it's now key to defeat Islamophobia by reversing the distraction and redirecting our energies to identifying, de-fanging and isolating the perpretrators of both the Islamophobic distractions and the root cause of the aggressor's discontent.
What is needed now is a 'De-Bushification' of our town hall meetings, Capitol Hill Machinations and imminent 2012 campaign.
Grass roots efforts to directly and forcible confront Islamophobia will have limited results as it invariably plays into the hands of the bigoted perpetrators.
mahmoud el-darwish
JH
3:31 pm on Thursday, September 29, 2011
The above statement by Mahmoud sounds like nonsense to me. Fear of Islam is a direct result of the 9/11 attack on America. Any concerns or fears that some people may have had prior to that time were minor. It will take many many years, if not decades, for Americans to begin to get past the fear and distrust created by the twisted bigoted fanatics from the Middle East that attacked our homeland. The 9/11 terrorists ( acting in the name of their religion) should be the focus of your anger.
Don't blame the victims, blame the terrorists.
Aref Dajani
6:36 am on Friday, September 30, 2011
As a Muslim-American, I can tell you firsthand that Fear of Islam happened before 9/11. When I was in high school, Americans were held hostage at the U.S. Embassy in Tehran. Not a great time to be a Muslim in America. But it's not about about my religion and never has been. People are afraid of the different, of what they don't understand.
In the 1940s, Americans put Japanese-Americans who had lived here for generations in internment camps, courtesy of Pearl Harbor. We saw a resurgence of hatred against the Japanese in the 1970s when we were in a recession. We blamed Japan -- and thus Japanese-Americans -- for the loss of American jobs. The Ku Klux Klan targets Vietnamese-Americans in the Gulf today for their success in the shrimping industry.
When the world suffered a global depression in the 1930s, Hitler blamed the Jews, the gypsies, the gays, the disabled, the Catholics, and pretty much anybody else who did not fit his Aryan ideal. Twelve million people were slaughtered as a result.
JH, the response to fear is not love, but information! Engage us American-born Muslims, whether converts or not. Some of us are actually literate! Listen to how we were shattered TWICE by 9/11: first by the loss of innocent lives on our American soil, then the backlash against us, where women wearing headscarves were afraid to leave their houses, afraid of being attacked.
Engage us, JH, and experience our humanity. You'll learn that Islam is nothing anyone has to fear.
Nisi Hamilton
9:03 am on Friday, September 30, 2011
If you think Muslims are getting a bad rap, then you are in the right country to voice your opinion, thank God. This country and its heritage supports your right to speak on this forum and in clubs, parks, Congressional floors, and even in private houses to say what you think.
But if you want real respect for your faith and culture, then get on out there, all you Muslim Americans, and work vocally and loudly against the radical Islamic agenda. Don't spend your time saying how much you're hated and line yourselves up with the progressive left who want to shut down any free speech that isn't their own.
Stand up for liberty, even if the people exercising that liberty peacefully don't echo your own sentiments - because that's what it is to be American.
Disagree with them all you want. But do not tell them that they don't have the right to speak.
Oh and who, pray tell, will decide what "biased speech" is and what isn't? That suggestion sounds like something out of a George Orwell book.
NH
JH
9:09 am on Friday, September 30, 2011
Aref ---- I urge you to reach out to those fanatics ( and their support network here and around the world) that attacked America and let them understand and embrace the love that you feel for the American people. You can have a positive impact and play a constructive role in the war on terror. Start today!
Saqib Ali
12:19 pm on Sunday, October 2, 2011
"Stand up for liberty, even if the people exercising that liberty peacefully don't echo your own sentiments - because that's what it is to be American.
Disagree with them all you want. But do not tell them that they don't have the right to speak."
Hilarious. We held a public forum at which we invited Fred Grandy to discuss his views. He failed to show up because he fears public debate of his views alongside informed opponents. So we did EXACTLY Nisi Hamilton is recommending. Yet she is still blasting American Muslims.
This "logic" is absurd and ridiculous on its face. And it belies a deeper prejudice.